I like the first one cause the colours feel like they match the Char, but the glass shatter looks more real in the 2nd one and the contrasty look is kinda blinding but really interesting :)
I prefer the first one because the de-saturated colors seem to better support how deserted and dirty the street is...but I'm not sure if that's what you're going for. I agree with Jess, the 2nd one is a bit of an eye-sore even though it's much more dramatic.
I'd go with the first one, contrast is nice looking but the character pops better with the first one : )
ok thanks guys, there will actually be traffic on the streets, but i havent done that yet, it will be animating.